Уважаемые деятели в сфере авторского права и смежных прав!
Кто интересуется темой либерализации копирайта, предлагаю вам свою идею.
Как вы считаете, может ли такая система быть реализована на практике (в сфере коллективного управления)? Если да\нет, то какие её преимущетва\недостатки?
Или какие вы встречали существующие налаженные схемы добровольного вознаграждения за использование объектов авторского права\смежных прав.
Описание - в подкасте на русском (mp3, 38 минут):
http://biznes-finansy-investicii.rpod.ru/56363.htmlИ далее переписка на английском (+добавлен сегодняшний ответ ответ от SCHLYTER Carl)
Richard Stallman - основатель GNU\GPL
Lawrence Lessig - основатель Creative Commons
Carl Schlyter - продюсер проекта
http://iwouldntsteal.net/Richard Stallman Date: 28.11.2007, 06:17:04
The hard part of these systems is not designing them.
It is convincing governments to implement them.
----------
Lawrence Lessig Date: 08.01.2008, 03:18:33
It's a great idea, though I myself have moved to other areas of research. Good luck in its promotion!
------------
SCHLYTER Carl 13.03.2008, 10:27:56
Thankyou, Richard is right that corporate lobbying is the biggest obstacle, but in any case the more solutions we propose the bigger the chance that one will one day become reality.
-------------
On Nov 27, 2007, at 8:18 AM, Alex wrote:
…
I want to tell you what I think about free culture and gift economy
I can call my idea "Free\open source and the system of free personal remuneration"
(I'm sorry for my bad English)))
Free soft, free works free phonograms, free everything
Well, I'm ready to pay FREE REMUNERATION!!!
But not like "Donate Wikipedia" etc...I want to Donate to certain work
Open society needs collective management organisations (CMO) to collect and distribute free remuneration for every certain rightholder, to promote this idea between authors, producers and users.
I think that nowadays means of payments allow to realise the Idea of free personal payments "from personal user to personal rightholder"
Let's imagine how it could work:
There is an agreement between rightholders of a work-members of CMO . The main conditions are: free dist
ribution free remuneration, and precentage division between rightholders.
CMO has an electronic data base, where every work has it's ID number
If I (as user) want to make a free payment I can type an ID and see online Information about this work and (or the name of work and see ID). The ID must be included in RMI of every work (rights management info) - located in paper covers or electronic text tags.
The system of online ID-checking must allow for user to check whether ID is right and exclude RMI-squatting
User must have many different ways how to pay: SMS, Internet-money, Credit-card etc.
I think that there are 2 the easiest (and most effective worldwide) ways of payments
1) SMS-money:
You send an SMS with ID and amount of money you want to pay. Then Mobile Operator moves this amount of money from your account to the account of certain work managed by CMO
If the sum reaches e.g. 100$ the remuneration is distributet between rightholders due to agreed proportions
The payments of remuneration collected by CMO for rightholders are regular: every monts, year
2) Cards:
You buy e.g 5$, 10$...100$-card and have your virtual account from which you can virtually pay free remuneration to different rightholders
3) automatic cash terminal (in shops, supermarkets etc). In CIS countries "I-boxes" where you can pay for different services like digital cable TV or mobile account became very popular
The system of free remuneration (SFR) must work if user can easy-way-to-pay.
As a stimulation can be a system of available online info about free-sponsors (if user thinks that he\she is proud to tell everyone that he\she supports some author\producer\another rightholder and how much he\she donated )))
The philosophy of regular free payments: every day I use many works for free and every week I''m ready to pay some money to those creators, whose work I like most or whose creative work I want to support
Big-budget projects can be also realiset by before-during-after free-payments: announcing about idea-collection of necessary sum for realisation-realisation-free payments for good realisation
CMO also must have a server of free works or identify every ID with the link from which the work can be downloded.
Or have an Internet-portal of free-works\blogs\comments. A fair system of raitings (users votes)must popularize the best works and sift out "free junk"
All national free CMOs (FCMO) must have reciprocal agreements between each other so each of them can collect free remuneration abroad
etc etc etc...